Showing posts with label review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label review. Show all posts

Monday, November 10, 2014

Late to the Show: District 9


While I was in the gym today, the TV was on and the Peter Jackson flick District 9 was playing in a movie channel that I'm not familiar with. I was paying as much attention as I can because it was a very interesting movie, but by the end of it, I felt glad that I didn't watch it in the theater. I'm pretty ambivalent about it. It's the kind of movie that is fun to watch and is a great choice for if you like something that makes you think, but it's also not something I would like to give a second viewing.

The movie starts with a semi-documentary style of cinematography with random interviews intercut with footage of aliens living on Earth. A race of alien creatures nicknamed "prawns" are stranded on Earth and are compelled to settle in South Africa, where the government is launching a relocation program for the prawns. Our hero is idealistic Wikus van der Merwe, an agent of the paramilitary organization Multinational United, who leads the relocation program by issuing eviction notices to the prawns. The prawns are understandably upset about this situation. Wikus, on the other hand, is a righteous kind of guy who does not approve of violence against the prawns.

There are a lot of things I like about this movie. The actors were great. The visuals were great. The characters were believable. It was also refreshing to see a sci-fi film with a contemporary setting rather than the typical futuristic setting. However, something about the concept is a bit off.

District 9 is clearly meant to be a sci-fi allegory of immigration problems and racial tension in first world countries by setting it in South Africa, which has a long history of racial segregation known as the apartheid. The hatred and violence that the humans commit against the prawns are reminiscent of the unfortunate circumstances that happen to many black and Hispanic people even in the United States. We are clearly meant to squirm guiltily in our seats as we watch the humans attack the prawns with little to no provocation, with the morally upright authorities being ironically powerless to stop it. By painting the humans as the villains, we are essentially villains in our own countries for wanting unregistered immigrants (aliens) out of our lands when they're evidently harmless.

But I think there's something wrong with that idea. The further I watch the movie, I don't find myself rooting for the aliens at all. Why shouldn't the humans want them out? If the South African government is going through the trouble of relocating them to an internment camp away from the slums the aliens have built for themselves, why should we feel bad that the prawns feel hurt and refuse to cooperate? If they wanted to go home so badly, why don't they just, y'know, leave?

I think it's not fair for a people of one country have to bend over backwards to respect the "rights" of foreigners who don't even hold the same privileges as the citizens of that country. Of course it's wrong for, for example, an American to be violent toward a Mexican; or for an Italian to spit at a Jew's beard. But there are more issues to consider other than discrimination or violence, like obeying the principles of law and order when you're in somebody else's territory. A host might have the responsiblity to treat their guests right, but the visitor has to be a good guest, too, by removing their shoes, refraining from expletives, and dressing modestly, if necessary.

District 9 seems to oversimplify the moral against racism. Immigration laws are more complicated than racism, and racism is more complex than we probably think, to begin with. District 9 is a good-but-not-great kind of movie. Its flaws are few but jarring. If I got something wrong, feel free to correct me.

Wednesday, October 30, 2013

Old Vs. New: Carrie


Contrary to the popular belief that remakes can never surpass the original, the 2013 adaptation of Stephen King’s first novel Carrie is a huge improvement from the 1976 classic.

Carrie is the story of a 16-year-old telekinetic girl who was being bullied at school and sheltered by a fanatically religious mother. Carrie eventually gets pushed way too far at prom and unleashes her devastating power on everyone. Most people know the details by now; for those who don’t, that’s all I can tell you.

The 1976 movie adaptation is a classic for all the good reasons. It is chilling because it rings true to our fears when it comes to both conventional society and public relations. It highlights religion as a potential obstacle to progress; at least, that’s the interpretation most people get from it. True to its source material, Carrie is a compelling and effective cautionary tale about bullying.

The same is true for the 2013 remake, but it is neatly updated to its present-day setting and with additional depth to the story and its characters.

The horror is quite subdued. The heightened suspense and drama intensifies the thrilling climax that followed.
I think the movie doubles as a commentary on the present American society and its various ups and downs. Adults Are Useless but only because they're either just as clueless as the teenagers they handle or spread out too thin keeping things how they should be. I especially enjoyed this one: the tanned brunette Chris Hargensen is just as vicious as her pretty blonde counterpart in 1976, but she is also, quite plainly, just a spoiled brat.

The special effects achieved where the "original" didn't. In 1976, movie trends and conventions were obviously limited and some of those which were used came out silly (the music and Psycho Strings, for example). This remake had the perfect tools to intensify the horror of the story throughout the movie. The camera angles and additional scenes give the movie the right tone and atmosphere and, surprisingly, humanizes almost ALL characters.
If it counts, the new Carrie is a marvelous example of Characterization Marches On. In this adaptation, nobody is completely good or evil even though Carrie and Sue are obviously the most sympathetic ones. It feels a lot like Mean Girls where Regina George is the way she is because she has lousy parents. The school bullies are self-centered kids; the gym teacher is a well-meaning but misguided counselor; and Sue Snell and Tommy Ross are pretty much Average Joes that just want to do the right thing for once.
Julianne Moore's performance can remind you of Sigourney Weaver as Lady Claudia in Snow White: A Tale of Terror. She was frightening, menacing, and sympathetic, all at the same time. Julianne Moore, unsurprisingly, exceeds expectations in her performance as Margaret White. The script, thankfully, gives the character depth. Her moral dimensions are badly warped, but she does love Carrie, somewhat. Chloƫ Grace Moretz also delivered excellently as the title character. Both actresses handled the dynamic as the dysfunctional religious family in the suburbs in Maine.
Oh yeah, there are nice touches of realism in the script, too. Mrs. White has a job; she's not entirely a Complete Monster; and she and Carrie actually genuinely love each other. They just have really serious problems especially because Mrs. White's morality and reality are badly warped. It's an improvement; the 1976 adaptation was more faithful to the book in that aspect, but this new addition gives it a refreshing touch and therefore a more horrific and heartbreaking dynamic between the two characters.

The prom scene and the preceding telekinesis clips are impressive. We see an immensely satisfying destruction to the school gym and everyone who hurt Carrie there. I felt exactly the way I did when I first read the book when I was 13.

Monday, April 16, 2012

The Hunger Games Review


Maybe it's early for me to say that
The Hunger Games was a disappointed; in fact, I'm disappointed with myself for being disappointed with it because I haven't even read the books and have only got the vital information on the story from my sister who recently downloaded and audio book and loved it. While I do not doubt the credibility of the book (I still intend to buy the full set to see if I might change my mind) or the skill of its author, I have quite a few problems with the characters.

Before I delve into the negative criticism, let me just point out that I do not hate The Hunger Games. I am actually impressed with this vision of a post-apocalyptic world. Although I have yet to understand why the Capitol wants to kill off a good chunk of the population that can rebuild human civilization, I like how it somehow becomes an allegory of the world today. I think it is socially relevant and really makes you think about how many governments leech out what's left of their nations' poor to exploit them as if it is a game.

This leads me to my strongest criticism of the story: I think it could have done well without a specific protagonist. I think it would have been better if each of the Tributes have their own place in the narrative, thus giving the plot more meat. By this I mean I think it would have been better if we focused on the Capitol's bullshit instead of one teenage girl's bullshit.

There, I said it: The Hunger Games' biggest flaw is its protagonist. While I understand her background and where she's coming from, I find myself not feeling for this character. As I watch as Katniss Everdeen pines for her hometown and she subsequently runs and fights for her life, I find myself idle. I don't feel like I care for this character.

Contrary to popular belief, good characterization is not all about 'relating' or identifying with her; I think it is more on caring for the character. It means you want her to succeed and survive and be happy by the end (or feel tortured for her failing). And I feel nothing like that for Katniss.

I do not hate Katniss, but I don't like her either. The first thing that turned me off about her was how she insults her mother just as she's saying goodbye. "No matter what you feel, you have to be there for her!" she orders her old lady. And before that, she is just dismissive on the woman. Okay, I understand Katniss is a teenager with her own brand of self-centeredness (this is not an insult; every teenager is self-centered at some degree). But just because she loves her sister like a daughter doesn't mean she is a wonderful, thoughtful, self-sacrificing martyr or something. If you want me to believe that, she has to understand the dynamics of loving someone; with her mother, apparently not.

The poor woman is devastated over the untimely death of her husband; while I can understand that Katniss would be angry with her for her subsequently becoming unsupportive of her two young daughters, leaving young Katniss to become the parent in the family, I think Katniss should have had better sense than to talk to her mother like that especially as she's literally facing the possibility of death. I know Katniss is not readily perceptive of the idea of falling in love. However, I think, as a woman, she should grasp better the idea of how awful it is to share your life, your soul, to someone who gives you two beautiful daughters, only to have him practically stolen from you by fate. While her mother definitely becomes halfway irresponsible, it would have been nice if Katniss stops to think: "Hey, this is my mother. I should cut her some slack now that I might never see her again."

Any chance of me giving a damn about Katniss spirals down further when I find myself rooting for some of the other characters, including seemingly antagonistic tributes like the older Black guy, the gorgeous blond guy, or the vicious knife-thrower. Despite their seeming cruelty, I find myself rooting for these characters (sorry I can't remember their names at the moment) because you have to remember that, like Katniss, they were brought to the Hunger Games against their will. They learned early on that they have to kill to survive. Despite how disgusting the concept is, I respect these characters because you just know that one basic fact, and it's enough. They don't need to resort to sob stories to take them seriously, like supposedly living in the "poorest town" of the "poorest district" where you support your family alone because your father died and your mother seemed to stop caring. But with Katniss, she seems to have all these hardships and still be awesome (with her hunting skills) and yet give me a reason to feel sorry for her. No, I'm not buying it.

And for a supposedly mature and cerebral young woman, she is extremely indecisive. I never really know what she wants in life. Sure, there are her responsibilities with her family, but other points in the plot seems to point to something involving romance. I accept that, so why can't this story just outright tell me that she's somehow interested in raising a family except she 's afraid to? Why resort to the Twilight standard "oh-I'll-just-play-with-this-other-guy's-feelings-to-test-if-I-feel-the-same-way" game?

This leads me to another peeve that irks even male fans of the franchise: Peeta is too wimpy to be taken seriously as a leading man. Don't give me that crap about him and Katniss "complementing" each other, because they don't. From the first time he and Katniss decide to be a team in the Hunger Games, all he ever does is whine and cry.

Look, I've seen men cry before, and it doesn't normally bother me. However, it does bother me that Peeta cries and Katniss is meant to become the strong one for him. While there are narratives pertaining to this type of situation, there are some narratives that do it well; The Hunger Games does not. If anything, its sole purpose is to make Katniss look good in contrast. A good writer should never have to resort to that contrived trick especially when you are dealing with a pair of characters of opposite sexes.

After some good exposure to feminist film and literature, I have since learned that so-called feminist authors are just as guilty as their male "adversaries" in demonizing the other sex. Is male demonization present in The Hunger Games? I can't tell yet. But there is definitely some Twilight-grade objectification. Peeta seems to exist to be an ornament for a contrived love triangle that shouldn't even exist when you already have something socially relevant and emotionally compelling like, you know, THE HUNGER GAMES!

Besides, if Katniss is interested in Gale, her friend from her hometown, she should have known better than to play with Peeta like that, especially when she already knows he has the hots for her. And again, why should I even bother paying attention with this subplot when I would have been happier to learn more about the other Tributes? Ugh…this is making me agitated. I think I'll write a Part 2.

Friday, October 14, 2011

What Would Edward Do?


I remember telling myself that I would finally stop ranting about Twilight. For a while, I have ceased talking about it, although I have entertained hateful thoughts about it from time to time. Also after finally reading all four books and the spinoff novella in PDF and the first three movies, I have also decided that the Twilight series is not worth the attention it is getting. When it comes to the hatedom, however, I believe that it is necessary to promote understanding as to why Twilight is what I and countless others like me think it is.

Perhaps what contributed to my recent silence toward the series is that I have been busy writing a couple of pieces of fan fiction set seven years after the series finale, with my favorite character, Leah Clearwater in the lead. Time and again, I have expressed through my stories my own interpretation of the characters particularly those I dislike, like Bella Swan, Edward Cullen and Sam Uley. Hell, I have even criticized otherwise likeable Dr. Carlisle Cullen, blaming him along with Bella for any unnecessary and pointless conflict in the series and their tragic outcomes. I am referring in particular to the death of poor Bree Tanner, who was executed by the Volturi just for being involved; she hasn’t done anything, not even stepping foot into the actual battlefield. I am also talking about the dozens of innocent people who were either turned into vampires and then killed or killed by these vampires as their meal.

Anybody who has read Twilight or the movie adaptations tend to blame Victoria for the unnecessary tragedy. But I blame Bella nonetheless. If she hadn’t been there on that fateful baseball game, James wouldn’t have run after her; Edward wouldn’t have killed him, driving Victoria on a vengeful rampage. I would even say that Victoria was a brave woman to have gone through the trouble of risking tipping off the Volturi just to kill one puny human with unnecessary protection, but that’s for another essay.

What concerns me now is an entirely different matter. Last year, I wrote a blog entry bemoaning the lack of appropriate conclusion for Leah Clearwater. I wrote a piece of fan fiction to appease my grief over the injustice of it all. Then, to see if the happy ending does not falter, I wrote a sequel set eight years after the ending of the first one; I suggest you read it here before you continue reading.

The plot concluded the way I wanted and the way it would naturally flow according to the circumstances. So far, I’ve only had two reviews. One is pleased with the ending, and another is not. The latter said: “Was a asome plot and story up till the last chapter. I hated it not that Im a bella and Edward lover but It really was off of character that stephine meyers made them to be. yeah Edward is real pain when it comes to protecting his family but I don't think he would be that way. Like Said great story up to last chapter.”

If you have read the story, you would see that I somehow made all characters as close to the canon as possible. But as a fan fiction writer, I believe it is also my duty to incorporate some of my interpretation into the story and into the characters. If you would check the author’s profile page, I made it clear that I am not a fan of Twilight, and I don’t share the fans’views about it. However, my general opinion of the books is mostly irrelevant here; the matter on hand is the character of Edward Cullen.

Edward has always struck me as an arrogant, devious and intrusive stalker who resorts to deceit and emotional manipulation to get what he wants. I think that, even in his few moments of genuine affection, he gets carried away by his own emotions because of his stunted maturity. He has no reason to love Bella, much less a reason to hate Jacob or his wolf-brothers (and sister). And even if I believe he does, Edward doesn’t give me a reason to care. The primary reason I don’t care for anything he thinks or says or does is because I blame him and Bella (and to a lesser extent, Carlisle Cullen) for anything that ever happens in the series; in fact, I root for Victoria for wanting to kill the little bone-bag and going through the trouble of making a newborn army just to kill someone who doesn’t deserve my sympathy.

If a heartbroken vampire is an unstoppable destructive force, isn’t Victoria only acting upon her own instinct and emotion suitable to that of a true vampire? And James, he wouldn’t have died if Bella wasn’t even in the secret baseball field with the damn Cullen family!

Okay, let’s think of it this way: if Bella did die, wouldn’t Edward be pissed and go on a quest to kill Victoria? If he is the protagonist, you would have rooted for him, right? Well, the same thing happened to Victoria; why would you still root for Edward and not her? What is it about Bella that she is so important?—that she is his “true love”? WHY is she his true love? That’s what I don’t understand! And I don’t need anybody to tell me to understand anymore. I’ve read all four books and the pointless spinoff novella. I’ve seen the three movies, and I am willing to see the next two. The series is ending, and nothing is there that could show me why I should care that Edward and Bella should be together.

In fact, I don’t think they deserve a happy ending. Leah Clearwater does because her life sucks, and she doesn’t deserve to feel hurt. Feel free to read my blog entry here to see why.

Now, as I have stated, Edward is a selfish, overbearing jerk with no contribution to society and therefore does not deserve to exist. Okay, maybe that was a little harsh. There are many other characters—well-written characters of any given alignment—that have little or no contribution to their society. And that’s barely even the problem; my issue with Edward is that he doesn’t have a reason for me to care about him. His fangirls might try, but so far, anything important or ‘good’ I’ve heard about him are the shallow stuff: that he’s affectionate, “protective” and “devoted” to the point of being annoying but it’s okay because he’s hot and his heart is in the right place so he practically can do no wrong.

Except that he does get carried away by his passionate and fiery temperance and even those who love him (fellow characters or real-world fangirls) admit that he does make silly decisions or thoughts. So now we get to my final point: why would he then not act the way he did in the climax of “Wolf People II”? Based on his fans’ interpretation on him, how else would he have handled the fear that the only other supernatural beings closely allied to his family is keeping a secret that one of them is married to what they all consider a true monster? Why would the fans “not think he would be that way”? Under the given conflict and circumstances, what would he have done based on the intended character structure Stephenie Meyer intended him to be?

Okay, maybe dragging a man by his hair to his wife’s feet was a tad cruel coming from Edward Cullen. But think about this: openly insulting the second closest man to his significant other’s heart is not that much of a stretch. If he can repeatedly call Jacob Black with derogatory terms instead of his proper name, how much crueler can Edward Cullen possibly be to someone he has identified as an enemy? For goodness sake, he tore off a heartbroken woman’s head because he killed her mate! He didn’t bother to see Leah’s point of view when she berated Bella and made her cry; he was arrogant enough to claim he knows what Bella is feeling but Leah’s mind is an open book to him, and he doesn’t understand why she’s angry with Bella for breaking Jacob’s heart. If Leah wasn’t remotely important to Jacob, Edward might have killed her if you ask me. So what’s to stop him from wanting to kill Nanuq?

What else could he have reasonably done? Come on, my Twilighter friends. Enlighten me.

Thursday, December 9, 2010

Movie Review: Dilim (2005) *SPOILERS AHEAD*



Yesterday, I bought a VCD of a 2005 supernatural action film called Dilim, about a manananggal superhero that uses his superhuman abilities to fight crime. The word manananggal is derived from the word “tanggal” meaning “to remove, divide or sever”; a manananggal is a type of aswang that divides itself in half, leaving its lower half behind while the winged upper half hunts for human prey. I think it is really creative to transform this traditional symbol of evil and abjection into a tortured soul fighting for the common good. This is the first action film I've seen that did not involve rebels defending slum-dwellers or cops that arrive at the crime scene when the climax is over.

Dilim is an alias given to a mysterious crusader who fights criminals and saves the innocent. The local police chief refuses to consider “Dilim” a hero; he thinks the guy is “taking the law into his own hands” and keeps the police from doing their job. He has a lovely daughter named Elisa, who has been estranged from him after the death of her mother.

Afterwards, we see a handsome young loner hanging around at a dump site for scrap metal, where he makes friends with an old man and a little boy. The black-shirt-and-jeans-clad stranger barely speaks, only answering curtly when his new friends ask him questions. We know from the opening fight scene that this is “Dilim” in his human form. In the daytime, he tries to be normal except that he is antisocial. At the dump site, we see him dragging around a sack of the dead bodies, which we know from folklore that he will eat later.

A low-budget, made for television film, a Cinema One original, Dilim draws its strength from this creative reimagining of the manananggal. But for viewers that have high standards, some aspects of the movie might turn them off. Personally, I can’t decide if I hate it or not.

My biggest but least important complaint is the special effects. If you have seen the half-baked leak of X-Men Origins: Wolverine, it’s like that. It would have been great if they used simpler props and utilized camera angles and scene cuts instead of amateurish conspicuous CGI. The stunts and combative choreography are just about as bad. Wait, the choreography might be okay but they look rehearsed.

The night scenes supposedly filmed at rooftops uses CGI backgrounds too. This is a pity because the nighttime cityscape of NCR actually looks good, especially at Makati City and the coastline. The illuminated smog would have provided good lighting as well.

I appreciate the film crew for trying out CGI, but it’s not going to work if it’s only going to distract the viewer with how fake it looks. I would have gasped and exclaimed in excitement at the fight scenes, but I ended up laughing half the time.

The more important flaw of this film is that the hero is a Gary Stu. A Gary Stu is the male counterpart of a Mary Sue; a Mary Sue is a character that is underdeveloped, has no character flaws and is overly romanticized in one way or another. This is usually committed by amateur writers.

A primary complaint about a Mary Sue is that the character has an exotic name or an ordinary name with a glaringly special meaning. The title character commits both violations. He is nicknamed Dilim, because he appears in the dark alleys, at night, when his powers are in full force. To be fair, Dilim is only an alias given to him by the police. But I still think it’s a poor choice. After saving Elisa from a potential rapists and befriending her, we learn that Dilim’s real name is Eman, an increasingly popular nickname for Emmanuel, as an alternative to other nicknames like Manuel or Manny. Emmanuel is a name attributed to Jesus Christ because it is the name Isaiah prophesied that the Messiah will have. It means “God is with us.”

A second complaint about a Gary Stu is angst. This is a sensitive topic when discussing Mary Sues. Angst can work if executed well. But Eman complains about being “cursed” from start to finish. At one point, he asks the local priest, “Was I really created by your so-called God?” The angst includes a fascinatingly gruesome scene in which we see Eman crying while sewing himself where his body cuts in half. This is the best visual effect that the film shows. Some people might think it’s over the top, but I think it’s subtle because of its lack of dialogue. But if you’re a guy who can do a better job than the police in fighting crime, you’d think it’d be cool to use your demonic powers for good, right?

I also think that Eman’s tendency to be withdrawn and moody is a Gary Stu symptom. It all would have worked if the viewer is given sufficient reason BEFOREHAND to sympathize with him. But any source of sympathy is revealed only later so he can come off as “mysterious” for the most part of the film. This is really a pity because the big revelation comes only just before the climax. But because of the tension from anticipating the climax, I almost stop caring about the hero’s tragic past.

In the full revelation at the climax, we learn that Eman ran away from his village as a little boy after his father tells him to “run like we’re just playing tag.” The parents are distressed and you hear an angry mob approaching, apparently in search of the monster child. The fact that his father is played by the same actor in the role of Elisa’s father and that his mother “Karina” is seen in a metaphorical death scene, it could be implied that Elisa is really Eman’s sister. This makes for healthy speculation among the viewers. With that in mind, it could be assumed that when Eman tells Elisa that he loves her, it could be interpreted differently. He says, “I love you” and that’s it. It has an ambiguous feel to it that totally works.

It would have been better if we get a bigger view of Eman’s childhood in the village. But much of the backstory lives on ambiguity. Although this gives the audience a chance to think, it mostly makes the story feel hollow by the end.

But the biggest disappointments I have are the plot holes. Traditionally, the manananggal gets her powers from a magical ointment that she rubs all over her body to make the transformation possible. (She bathes in the morning to turn human again.) But we never see how Eman became a manananggal. Did a witch curse him? Is it congenital? We never know. There are potential plot points that can be bound together, like the main villain who is in league with a witch; it would have been interesting if the hag turns out to be the one who cursed Eman in the first place. But again, we never know.

In relation to that, I also have a problem with the fact that Eman doesn't sprout wings and fly until later. He is only shown to have superhuman strength and senses but he looks perfectly human. It also would have been interesting if we see him creeping into the crook's houses and sucking their blood with his threadlike tongue. WE DON'T SEE SUCH A TONGUE. The manananggal's threadlike tongue is essential to the creature just as the vampire cannot be a vampire without fangs. Oh, and remember when I said Eman drags dead bodies in his shelter? He is never shown eating them. It would have been easy! Raw meat is available in every wet market and for blood, there's chocolate with red food coloring.

And the highlight of the transformation was a disappointment. After writhing in agony for a few minutes, Eman goes after the bad guys and then, his demonic wings burst out and tear his shirt off. Done in crappy CGI, the scene made me end up laughing. Why didn't he just go out there shirtless? And I know he has sewn his midsection, but if his wings can tear his shirt off, why didn't his body get cut in half and pluck off the stitches? Shake, Rattle & Roll has done it better in 1984 and 1992!

What I loved about the film, however, is that the reimagining of the manananggal is innovative. There is an implication that the manananggal is not a symbol of evil as shown in folklore. Dilim/Eman becomes a sort of a Holy Knight toward the climax when, at the verge of his transformation, he approaches the priest, who tells him that God loves him no matter what.

Also in spite of the plot holes that are so huge that buses can fall into them, I like that the story is simple and there is minimal political commentary that you experience too much on television nowadays. The dialogue slides from archaic to colloquial from time to time, but I like that it is fluid and keeps the story at a consistent pace. The characters—even some of the good guys—have no trouble swearing and I like that a lot. Another of this movie's charms is that the plot echoes Spiderman but surprisingly doesn't push it. The urban atmosphere is not too romantic in the literary sense. The crime scenes are something that you see on the news everyday; there's a realistic touch.

The religious tone is gentle and simple. It deviates from the fundamentalist ideals of pacifism and instead uses it as an active force in fighting evil. The priest HANDLES A GUN and joins Elisa’s father in the hunt for the bad guys.

Despite all its flaws, Dilim was enjoyable for me for the most part. This is just what Philippine pop culture needs. Yes, Dilim needs a little more work in reimagining the local mythology but this is a huge step forward.

Monday, July 12, 2010

Review of The Short Second Life of Bree Tanner *SPOILERS AHEAD*

I’ve just read The Short Second Life of Bree Tanner: An Eclipse Novella online, and I was surprised to find it about twenty times more palatable than any of the four books in the Twilight “Saga”. Owing largely to its length, I finished it in one day—approximately 6 hours—minus about two hours in between that I spent eating and surfing the internet. It’s not at all better written than any of the books in the “Saga”; Meyer still committed “thesaurus rape” quite a few times, but not as much this time because by using Bree Tanner’s voice, she didn’t have to use ridiculously big words to attempt to sound intelligent like she did with Bella. Bree Tanner was only palatable because it’s more concise than usual (which I previously thought Meyer could never accomplish); although I would say that Bree Tanner could have been even shorter if Meyer could write any better.

I had been expecting the story to begin with the titular character being turned into a vampire; instead, we find Bree complaining about her companions who are “stupid” and rash and inexperienced.

At first, I thought we were going to have a Bella clone, but I was proven wrong later. We subsequently find out that Bree was appointed to be with these other new vampires by Riley, the leader of what we already know from Eclipse to be an even larger coven than just Bree and these few vampires. But Bree breaks away from this group to hang out with another vampire—a rather charming Hispanic boy named Diego, who later reveals that they do not combust in the sun as Bree had previously thought. After this encounter, Bree develops feelings for Diego. To my surprise, Meyer actually succeeded to be a bit more subtle about this than she did with Bella and Edward. Bree seems cautious about it; she becomes willing to call these feeling “romantic”, especially when Diego kisses her lips without warning, but she doesn’t suffocate the narrative with it because she’s more interested in observing what’s going on around her.

Among these observations were of a “college age” boy named Freaky Fred, who has “repelling” powers. I didn’t understand this at first, but I sort of understood later that his gift was similar to Bella Swan’s in Breaking Dawn. It’s like he can conjure a shield around himself, like Bella, but whoever gets close to it becomes “nauseated” and so compelled to keep distance. An offshoot of this ability is that by using this shield, he can make himself “invisible”, which I understood to be “undetectable” by other vampires rather than strictly “invisible”. Near the end, Fred becomes fond of Bree and urges her to run away to Canada with him and avoid the final battle with the Cullens, who they only know as the “yellow-eyes”. Bree agrees, but she tells Fred that she’ll catch up when she finds Diego, who Riley said was with Victoria, whose name was never revealed to the young vampires. Fred goes ahead to Canada while using his ability to go undetected by Riley and promises to wait for Bree and Diego for 24 hours while Bree looks for Diego at the edge of the battlefield only to find her large coven dwindling and dying.

You all probably know by now what happens in Eclipse, so it turns me off that the plot—Diego and Bree’s earlier motivation to find out Riley’s purpose for creating vampires so many and then Bree’s plan to run away after she realizes that Riley had been lying to them about burning in the sun and then hiding from them his and Victoria’s conniving with the “dark-cloaks” (the Volturi)—would be utterly pointless. That being said, it’s no doubt that this entire novella is pointless in itself. Bree does win my heart when she becomes determined to see through these tasks and then bravely faces death when she fails. But the fact that her courage and resolve accomplishes nothing really turns me off. I normally don’t mind tragic endings, but having no resolution is a big letdown.

Thursday, August 6, 2009

A Feminist Analysis of Ratatouille

Just for the record, I am not a feminist. Although I believe in the equality of the sexes, I do not believe in the adage, “A woman can do anything that a man can do.” Neither am I the kind of woman that would complain about Dolores Umbridge and Bellatrix Lestrange being the main villains of Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, and being second-in-command only to more powerful male villains. I don’t have a problem with having the desire to be taken care of. However, I have great respect for women—fictional or not—who know what they want and know how to get it, without letting any man to get in the way.

This brings my attention to the only female main character of the Pixar film Ratatouille, Colette Tatou. A chef in the kitchen of the gourmet restaurant Gusteau’s, Mademoiselle Colette is introduced as the mentor and partner of Alfredo Linguini, after he is mistakenly recognized as the creator of a fabulous new soup, which was really created by Remy the rat. “I am the only woman in this kitchen!” she says to Linguini on his first day of work. “I have been working too hard for too long to get here, and I am not going to jeopardize it for some garbage boy who got lucky!” (It is no surprise why she is an uptight nagger throughout the film. Tired women do that.)

It is clear that Colette has a strong personality. She can make Linguini shudder and recoil just by her mere presence. She initially sees Linguini as competition; it is her greatest misfortune to even be involved with him. “Haute cuisine is an antiquated hierarchy built upon rules written by stupid old men—rules designed to make it impossible for women to enter this world. But I’m still here,” she explains to him. To her, it shouldn’t matter that she is a woman; she can cook—and well, at that—and she is set to move beyond what the masculinist society dictates upon members of her gender.

Come to think of it, her motives are similar to Remy’s, who also wants to become more than what he really is. So now it bothers me that by the middle of the story, Linguini, under Remy’s control, has become the talk of the town just days after “his” soup’s popularity grew, and Colette lets it happen, putting her in the same position as she had been before. It bothers me even more that shortly after Gusteau’s reclaims its fame, she is shown to have given in to Linguini’s affections. It is implied that all she’s been looking for all along was love. She lowers her shield and lets an arrow pierce her, and that was it. All of a sudden, she is contented with being second place just when she’s halfway to her goal.

I understand that the theme of Ratatouille is “Anyone Can Cook.” Remy is a rat, and he has talent greater even than Colette’s. (His improvisation of the Sweet Bread a la Gusteau recipe became known as the “special order”; quite superior to the original, which was what Colette meant to serve; she was only following the rules.) Linguini, who cannot cook at all, is given a high position in the kitchen because people believe he can do it excellently. I understand that the audience loves the underdog. But doesn’t that make Colette, the only woman in the kitchen, sort of an underdog, too? I couldn’t accept that she’s been “working too hard for too long,” and suddenly it doesn’t matter because she fell in love. Who would have known that it would be a man that would soften her up?

And that’s another thing: Although I don’t have a real problem about women dreaming of someday having a stable family life with a man at their side to support them, I would agree that it is a masculinist notion that it is ideal that women would want exactly that. Walt Disney Pictures has been known to demonstrate through their films virtues that humanity holds dear—in the case of Ratatouille, perseverance against the odds. That being given, it could be deduced that even Colette’s behavior in the film was placed there that way on purpose. (Yeah, to make us go, “AWW…!” because she has a soft spot for Linguini—of all people.) That really seems disturbingly masculinist to me.