Showing posts with label book review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label book review. Show all posts
Thursday, November 13, 2014
Late to the Show: Anaconda
I finally dared myself to watch "Anaconda" after watching Todd in the Shadows' review of it:
I kept encountering thumbnails in the Internet about how controversial it is. And after hearing it a few times in the radio, I've become curious about the music video. But for a long time, I refused to watch it. I refused to go anywhere near it because I remember how violently I felt about Miley Cyrus' "We Can't Stop" and "Wrecking Ball," and I didn't want that kind of unnecessary negativity in my spirit. So I asked around about the video, and somebody I trust told me that "Anaconda" was so awful it's actually more shocking than anything Lady Gaga came up with.
With Lady Gaga as a reference point, I was somewhat disappointed when I did watch "Anaconda" on YouTube. Besides the overt innuendo and objectification in the video, there was nothing in "Anaconda" that really sets it apart from any other hip-hop hit. Sex sells—Nicki Minaj is all about sexy—you do the math. As for the song, it's fun to listen to; and it doesn't seem to be the kind of song you would really think about when you listen to it—just like any other hip-hop song as of late. It's the same with the music video. I've seen the same kind of imagery before with 50 Cent, Puff Daddy, Pharrell, or Snoop Dogg.
But I do agree with Todd in the Shadows about one thing: that nasty attack on "skinny bitches" toward the end of the song. People, let's get this straight: Becoming comfortable and happy about being on the heavy side does not give anyone license to say that thin people are unattractive. People of all shapes and sizes are beautiful in their own way; let's leave it at that. If you want an example of a beautiful thin person, take Keira Knightley.
Other than that, "Anaconda" isn't all that "shocking" in any way. Before I actually heard the song, I expected that it was shocking because it's about some guy's anaconda, if you know what I mean. That was disappointing, too. I was really expecting Nicki to be singing about admiring her man's anaconda. As a straight woman, I think that would have been pretty interesting. Instead, well, as Todd in the Shadows described it, it only rehashed "Baby Got Back" and added nothing much to it. "If you wanted a song about butts, why don't you just listen to that?" he demanded. You got me, Todd.
Saturday, March 30, 2013
The Hunger Games review
Unlike the futuristic concepts of decades
ago, The Hunger Games depicts a
future that is not far from our present. In what was once known as North
America, there is a small nation called Panem. Panem is governed by the
Capitol, surrounded by twelve districts, each serving the Capitol with its
specialties in trade and commerce. However, the Capitol also happens to be a
corrupt government that subjects the twelve districts to the annual Hunger
Games, a gladiatorial tournament that gathers a boy and a girl, ages twelve to
eighteen, from every district to fight to the death.
On the 74th Hunger Games, a
sixteen-year-old girl from District 12 named Katniss Everdeen volunteers to
enter the Games, taking the place of her twelve-year-old sister Primrose “Prim”
Everdeen, whose name was drawn.
The good …
Like Doug Walker, also known as the
Nostalgia Critic, I appreciate that this post-apocalyptic allegory of
contemporary pop culture acknowledges that its very young target audience can
handle the intensity of its contents. I think the concept is tight and clever,
and it is cleverly done. This reimagined future of civilization is haunting and
manages to be believable.
I like that the narrative is fast-paced.
The deceptively thick book can be finished in two to three weeks—one if you
have enough spare time. The way the plot escalates is another factor; no matter
what you like or dislike about the book, you will want to keep reading. This
was true for me even if I’ve seen the movie before reading the book; besides, I
wanted to know if there was anything I missed.
Well, I did miss one thing, and it was
actually one of the cleverest parts of the movie: the supposed love triangle.
Because we can’t have the movie adaptation told exactly as it was shown in the
book, so in the movie, it kinda fell flat. Although Haymitch and Effie in the
movie encouraged Katniss to keep up with Peeta’s declaration of love on
national television, there was nothing in the dialogue that suggested it was
all for show. I actually believed that Peeta really was in love with Katniss
while Katniss is confused by her own hormones and decided to play with the boy.
The movie handled it poorly, and I shall get to that later. The book, on the other
hand, handled it much better.
While Katniss is set on not marrying and
having children because she doesn’t want to put her future children into the
Hunger Games, she clearly has feelings for her best friend Gale. She claims he
is the only one she is fully comfortable with, the only one she readily smiles
for—more on that later. Anyway, so Katniss has sworn to stay single, which is
not to say she openly rejects romance or the possibility of it. She would be
happy to look forward to a future with Gale if it weren’t for the Hunger Games,
and Gale feels the same. Peeta comes into the picture, claiming on national
television that he has a crush on Katniss. The media presents this as reality
TV drama.
To my surprise, I actually became fond of
Peeta. It is true that they say that he and Katniss complement each other. He is
good at the things she’s not good at; and she is good at the things he’s not
good at. He is not a good combatant, but he has remarkable showmanship while
Katniss can put up a fight though putting on a show takes great effort from
her. I like this setup even though it is still clear that Peeta is created the
way he is to make Katniss seem strong and independent by comparison.
The bad …
The
Hunger Games is told entirely in Katniss’s first
person point of view, in an attempt to display the horrors of the Hunger Games
from the eyes of its doomed participant. The Hunger Games is a dehumanizing
so-called tradition of a so-called society, not unlike how present-day reality
shows allow their so-called stars to lose their dignity in exchange for money
while the viewers end up taking these shows too seriously. Knowing this, it
probably doesn’t matter what the background the protagonist comes from. I don’t
think it matters what the protagonist thinks of the games. The constant is that
it is an unnecessary sacrifice to make, especially for an already-crumbling
nation. Yet “acclaimed” author Suzanne Collins feels the need to shove a sob
story in there.
Now, Katniss has had a hard life.
Apparently, District 12 is the poorest district, where people regularly die of
starvation. Katniss had to singlehandedly keep her family from meeting that
fate by hunting in the woods with her best friend Gale. Katniss’s father died
when she was 11 years old, and her mother went catatonic, neglecting her two
young daughters for several months on end, essentially leaving them to fend for
themselves. Katniss has hated her ever since. I don’t see any purpose in this
except for the reader to take pity on Katniss. I think this is unnecessary
because being drawn into the Hunger Games at all is a horrific tragedy in
itself. I have an impression that this also gives the character an excuse to
justify complaining about her lot in life in every opportunity.
As you would read from my review of the
movie adaptation, I was repelled by the incredibly grumpy protagonist. I had
been hoping I would like Katniss better if I read the books; to my
disappointment, she was even worse there. Don’t get me wrong; I understand
where she’s coming from. Most readers recognize her poor behavior as symptoms
of post-traumatic stress disorder. From her background, it’s actually not very
surprising. But I think this could have been handled better.
One of the greatest things that bother me
about Katniss’s troubles is her relationship with her mother. Katniss “cannot
forgive” her mother for neglecting her and her sister Primrose following the
death of her husband in a mine accident. I suppose it would be reasonable to be
resentful because, after all, it is a mother’s duty to care for her children
regardless of her own troubles. But this is no excuse for Katniss to fault her
mother for it by giving backhanded insults at dinner, distancing herself from
her unless being otherwise hostile, and yelling at her just before Katniss goes
off to the Hunger Games. Katniss may be hard-worn from the constant threat of
starvation, but I find it hard to believe that she has so little emotional
capacity to understand what her mother was going through and reach out to her instead.
Katniss missed her dear father as much as her mother missed her husband. Even
if they missed the same person in very different ways, I think Katniss should
have had the capacity to think, “Hey, my mother is so lonely, and I’m lonely,
too. Maybe if we mourn together, we won’t feel as bad.”
Obviously, she doesn’t have the capacity.
Maybe it’s the malnutrition reducing her cognitive skills, but I digress. What
bothers me about this is that in no way that this behavior is presented as
wrong. Just because Katniss is the protagonist, everything she does is somehow
justifiable. If she’s angry, she can rile against her mother all she wants.
Nobody calls Katniss out for it—not even Primrose, who actually gets along with
her mother.
The ugly …
I probably wouldn’t mind Katniss pointing
out how horrible her life is, but her language is always so full of hate and
contempt and general unhappiness that it exhausts me rather than drawing any genuine
sympathy from me. We constantly get reminded how her life is a constant
struggle and how sorry she feels for herself having to be the only one to feed
her family and being angry with her mother for doing nothing. “I can never
forgive her,” she says several times throughout the book, especially in the
first act. She has been worn to the point of being emotionless. Yes, we can
tell when she is being angry or sad, but we almost never witness her feeling
anything else. She says she loves her sister, but she had to say it rather than
demonstrate it besides the motherly way she cheers Prim up. We see how affected
Katniss is whenever she is with Rue, but there were way too little
demonstration of this affection.
Even smiling alone takes tremendous effort
from Katniss, and when she does it with genuine love as she shows hers to Gale,
it was told in a way that doesn’t come naturally for her. Some people don't smile because they are too depressed to smile with genuine happiness. While this is clear in Katniss's case, I got really annoyed that she says it like she has to remind herself to smile when around Gale, and not because she just smiles because it's him. None of this comes
off as natural or believable. Yes, I remember being this depressed when I was
also sixteen; smiling really does take tremendous effort, and my portraits from
that time were terrible. But keep in mind that stoic people, recognizable as people who almost never smile, never smile because they don't feel like it, not because they consciously choose to frown all the time.
This would not have been annoying at all if
it weren’t for Katniss constantly reminding the reader that being stoic is a
conscious effort. When she becomes aware that she is in the public eye, she
reminds herself to keep a straight face, apparently to hide any hint of fear or
sorrow. I honestly do not see any logical purpose to this. I think that if she
acts like herself, things might actually be better for her. We see glimpses of a
lighter and bubblier Katniss when she is with Gale, in the Hunger Games’
opening parade, and during interviews with Caesar Flickerman. Katniss might
argue that this is not her true self, but I would disagree. Whenever she lets
down her defenses, I find she can be quite charming. I like her better when she
is relaxed and comfortable. I even like her better when she is panicking over
the prospect of getting killed because it shows she is human. I don’t see why
or how being her charming self might impede on being the street-smart and self-sufficient
girl that she is. If anything else, consciously being stoic makes her come off
robotic and not at all likeable to anybody.
This makes me question why Cinna is so fond of her.
What bothers me most of all is that the
narrator’s language clearly demonstrates how little the author knows about the
third world. District 12 is a third-world region. Poverty and hunger prevails,
and people are compelled to seek illegal means to survive. There are clear
distinctions between classes, and there are known clashes and discriminations
between them. This is actually an accurate depiction of the third world; what
is actually wrong is the disposition of a person living in it.
In December last year, Gallup listed the
happiest and saddest countries in the world. The ten happiest countries
included eight Latin American countries and two Asian countries. As many people
know, Latin American countries tend to be impoverished due to corruption in the
government and the disorganized transition from simple rural life to fast-paced
urban living. This is also a serious problem in the Philippines, actually
number 8 in the list of happiest people in the world. Coming from the
Philippines, here is what I gather and which also Suzanne Collins completely
fails to understand: even with every reason to complain, poor people choose not
to.
Here in the Philippines, people have been
photographed grinning ear-to-ear while wading in waist-deep floodwaters.
Recently, a young couple was photographed on their wedding day waist-deep in
the flood. We are always reluctant to spend money on luxuries like some gadgets
and travel expenses; even those who can afford it would be happy to spend the
next year or so saving; but even then, we never fail to have a good time with
friends, or at least have a good laugh, especially snarky jokes against the
government. I don’t know how it is in Latin America, but I am guessing it is
similar, considering we are all former Spanish colonies: as my History teacher
said once upon a time, the secret to our happiness is “prayer and laughter.”
People who are well off may see some poor
people looking contented with their lives and think that poor people do not
know better. Well, I think they do know better: Poor people have every reason
to complain, but they realize it is a waste of time and energy to moan and
groan about things they know they can’t have. Poor people try to find ways to
find beauty and happiness around them because there is nothing to gain to keep
yearning for things they can want but will cost them too much. Staying positive
is the only way to survive. As Helen Morgendorffer of Daria put it, “It never is under control. We just tell ourselves
otherwise so we can function.” Poor people are satisfied that they manage to
get by, day by day. They might want to be rich, so they can afford to be fresh
and clean and beautiful and financially successful, and even famous, but they
are grounded enough to realize how little they can gain from dwelling on their
wants than anything they already have.
This is exactly what Suzanne Collins
doesn’t understand about living in the third world. Yes, I suppose any such
optimism can automatically be brought down several notches when there is a
clear threat to your life, but considering that Katniss points out that the
Peacekeepers in District 12 mostly leave the people alone, Katniss would
probably not dwell on her troubles that much.
Perhaps the poorest demonstration of this is
when Katniss scoffs at Rue’s love for music. She describes music as “as useful
as ribbons and rainbows,” meaning to say that she finds no real purpose for
these things at all; ergo, she has absolutely no appreciation for either music
or rainbows. It distinctively reminded me of Bella Swan saying, “Ew, snow,”
when taking a walk with her ‘friends’ in the first Twilight book. I really felt
like tearing the book apart when I read this line. It made me very angry
because I don’t understand how anybody
would not like music or rainbows. It’s
just not believable; it’s not natural; it’s not human. And Katniss being like
this destroys the purpose of her being the instrument of giving insight to how
horrible the Hunger Games is.
http://www.gallup.com/poll/159254/latin-americans-positive-world.aspx
Sunday, June 10, 2012
The Real Injustice Against the Hunger Games Tributes (Review Part 2)
The second part of my review of The Hunger
Games is long overdue, so I might as well finish it now. I have said in my
previous entry that while I am willing to give The Hunger Games a chance by
reading the book and really getting to know the protagonist beyond what I see
on the screen. However, I am very much put off by the excessive focus we have
on Katniss Everdeen. I think it would have been much better if there was no
specific protagonist at all; that way, we can see what each of the twenty-four
Tributes are going through in this barbarous competition.
I came to the theater knowing nothing
beyond the basic fact that there is a gladiator-like competition involving
teenagers and older children while one of them serves as the audience’s eye. I wasn’t
expecting to be expected to root for this one character, who is “talented”archer and huntress Katniss Everdeen, who lives in District 12 of the
post-apocalyptic nation of Panem. The concept is clever, and this highly
imaginative vision of the future is surprisingly believable. I even told my
sister that Lady Gaga might be a cultural icon to this world like Marilyn Monroe,
Jackie O, Audrey Hepburn, or Elizabeth Taylor is to us. And it’s believable
that way, and I like how it went that way.
Then, we are introduced to the mechanics of
the Hunger Games. I love how intentionally laughable it was. The concept alone
is an insult to anyone forced to participate. By the time this is revealed, we
have already been introduced to our “heroine” Katniss Everdeen, her pseudo-boyfriendGale Hawthorne, and her sister Primrose, who has been dreading the day she is
old enough to be selected as a participant in the Hunger Games.
Then, when it was revealed that there are
twenty-four other characters participating in the Hunger Games, I was thrilled.
Meeting new characters is like meeting new friends for me. I was looking forward
to learning about where they come from, what they are leaving, and what they
feel about being there.
After already witnessing how the Harvest
works (a cruel draw where their names are simply picked out from a fishbowl), I
felt concern over the twenty-two Tributes from the eleven other Districts. What
did they feel when they got chosen? Are they as sure as Katniss about winning? Oh,
there’s a gorgeous blond boy; this one’s bound to get a lot of screen time.
Alas, we were treated to an hour or so of
Katniss trekking, Katniss running, Katniss sleeping, and Katniss evading her “murderous”
opponents. This is the point where I get ticked off. For the next several minutes,
about five or seven of the remaining Tributes (practically ten of them died in
the first few minutes of the tournament) stalk Katniss and attempt to kill her
because she is apparently the strongest and most dangerous of them all. I am
prompted to ask why considering she hasn’t done anything vaguely threatening
except piss off the leaders behind the Hunger Games. Or was it that they’re
unrealistically impressed by her feisty attitude?
But what I’m even more irritated with is
that it’s obvious that the story is turning these characters out to be
villains. Why? Weren’t they also forcefully torn from their homes to compete in
this ridiculous competition? Aren’t they only doing the only thing they can do
to survive? Yes, I can see the malicious smiles on their faces, but I figure
that’s their way of dealing with their fears. Isn’t the Hunger Games an insult
to all of them equally? Why is this story trying to make me root for Katniss? What's making me so angry considering these facts, is that, as my best friend has said: "Yeah, nobody gives a fuck about how THEY FEEL."
I am more interested in these other characters. I want to meet them. I want to get to know them. I want to know of their hopes and fears. I want to know how they saw their future before getting drawn into the Hunger Games. If they have any hope of winning, what do they want to do with their victory? I am never given the answers to any of those because this story is giving unnecessary focus on Katniss, and I am not even sure why!
I am more interested in these other characters. I want to meet them. I want to get to know them. I want to know of their hopes and fears. I want to know how they saw their future before getting drawn into the Hunger Games. If they have any hope of winning, what do they want to do with their victory? I am never given the answers to any of those because this story is giving unnecessary focus on Katniss, and I am not even sure why!
For the next few months, I was convinced
this was a flaw with film adaptations of novels. You really can’t expect to
everything to be neatly translated between the two mediums. Maybe it was
deliberate to help non-readers understand what was going on. Once again, I was
sorely mistaken.
It was only days ago when I came upon a
comment—in YouTube, I think. I don’t quite remember what I was looking at—perhaps
a Hunger Games-related news clip or an interview with the cast. Maybe it was a
feature article from an entirely different website. Either way, there was some
sort of argument going on in the comments section. I didn’t bother with taking
a good look at what they were arguing about, but the highest rated comment is
apparently part of them. It said: “… Those kids who enjoy killing in the Hunger
Games, they are the villains!”
The V-word is an ugly word. I prefer not to
use that word except with a cast of characters in certain genres, and the genre
of The Hunger Games isn’t one of them. As far as I can tell, those kids who “enjoy”
killing in the Hunger Games aren’t enjoying it any more than Katniss does. But
they live in a cruel world, and they understand it is the only way they can
survive. They know they are helpless now that they’re in the Hunger Games. They
might as well do it with a smile because they know moaning about it isn’t going
to do anything lest they already have a knife to their throat.
I dunno, maybe that’s just me. Maybe it’s
the adaptation. Maybe it’s both. Either way, I refuse to believe that these
kids are villains. They’re desperate. They’re constantly on the verge of death.
What else would you do if you were in their shoes? I know Katniss must be
scared having to put up with them, but it’s not like they entered themselves in
the Hunger Games just to kill her. Why is this narrative trying to give me that
impression? It’s just so wrong.
Tuesday, September 29, 2009
Reading Anne Rice
When I read the Penguin Classics publication of Bram Stoker’s Dracula at the age of 13, I officially proclaimed myself a vampire fan. That was after I had watched the novel’s 1992 film adaptation, which was directed by Francis Ford Coppola. I loved the movie for its awesomeness and smooth storytelling; I loved the movie even more after I’ve read the book, because then, I had a better understanding of the vampire myth.
Unfortunately, despite my claims of becoming a vampire fan, Dracula remained to be the only sample of vampire literature that I actually read.
A few years passed, and many vampire movies became popular. I’ve watched Van Helsing, which I expected to be a mind-blowing back story for Abraham Van Helsing but turned out to be a fanfic crossover of Dracula and Frankenstein, (Seriously, where the hell did Victor come from?! Igor isn’t even supposed to be there!) AND disregarded a few facts about Dracula (only a werewolf can kill him?—puh-lease!) AND threw Abraham van Helsing out of the window. I came across trailers of Underworld and Blade, but never got to watch the movies. After such a time, I felt like I'm not worthy to call myself a fan of the vampire literature.
So, after finally watching the Interview with the Vampire movie, Nosferatu, and a few episodes of Buffy the Vampire Slayer and True Blood, I decided to pick up Anne Rice’s most popular work. I’ve read and heard people claiming that it’s the next best thing after Dracula, but I also encountered negative opinions. A classmate of mine claimed she didn’t like Anne Rice, but I didn’t ask her why, because I didn’t want to expose myself to negative opinion before making some of my own. Unfortunately, I have been exposed to some on YouTube, but the negative comments about Anne Rice turned out to be pretty tame.
Most of such comments basically said that Anne Rice is long-winded. I am now halfway through Interview, so now I can see what annoys some of its readers and fans. As it clearly explains on the title, it is an interview—a human interviewing a vampire in order to delve into the mind of a vampire, who somehow deviates from the evil vampire stereotype: Louis de Pointe du Lac, who is deeply in touch with his human nature, complains about killing people (and is ashamed of doing it even for the sake of his own existence) and the pains of immortality. It is a fresh story, and people love it for that new taste; however, it is an interview, so it should look like one. But as it approaches the middle of the story, it becomes more like a first-person narrative punctuated by questions from the human interviewer, which gradually becomes less and less essential because Louis seems to drone on and on as if he can tell the story on his own without the need for questions to continue.
At some point, I wondered if having the entire narrative in first-person point of view would have been better, because by the middle, when everything grew more and more intense, it didn’t sound like an interview anymore. It didn’t look like somebody telling a story to somebody else. After all, who would tell a story from over a hundred years ago with complete dialog and explicit detail?—and in an actual conversation, no less?
Unfortunately, despite my claims of becoming a vampire fan, Dracula remained to be the only sample of vampire literature that I actually read.
A few years passed, and many vampire movies became popular. I’ve watched Van Helsing, which I expected to be a mind-blowing back story for Abraham Van Helsing but turned out to be a fanfic crossover of Dracula and Frankenstein, (Seriously, where the hell did Victor come from?! Igor isn’t even supposed to be there!) AND disregarded a few facts about Dracula (only a werewolf can kill him?—puh-lease!) AND threw Abraham van Helsing out of the window. I came across trailers of Underworld and Blade, but never got to watch the movies. After such a time, I felt like I'm not worthy to call myself a fan of the vampire literature.
So, after finally watching the Interview with the Vampire movie, Nosferatu, and a few episodes of Buffy the Vampire Slayer and True Blood, I decided to pick up Anne Rice’s most popular work. I’ve read and heard people claiming that it’s the next best thing after Dracula, but I also encountered negative opinions. A classmate of mine claimed she didn’t like Anne Rice, but I didn’t ask her why, because I didn’t want to expose myself to negative opinion before making some of my own. Unfortunately, I have been exposed to some on YouTube, but the negative comments about Anne Rice turned out to be pretty tame.
Most of such comments basically said that Anne Rice is long-winded. I am now halfway through Interview, so now I can see what annoys some of its readers and fans. As it clearly explains on the title, it is an interview—a human interviewing a vampire in order to delve into the mind of a vampire, who somehow deviates from the evil vampire stereotype: Louis de Pointe du Lac, who is deeply in touch with his human nature, complains about killing people (and is ashamed of doing it even for the sake of his own existence) and the pains of immortality. It is a fresh story, and people love it for that new taste; however, it is an interview, so it should look like one. But as it approaches the middle of the story, it becomes more like a first-person narrative punctuated by questions from the human interviewer, which gradually becomes less and less essential because Louis seems to drone on and on as if he can tell the story on his own without the need for questions to continue.
At some point, I wondered if having the entire narrative in first-person point of view would have been better, because by the middle, when everything grew more and more intense, it didn’t sound like an interview anymore. It didn’t look like somebody telling a story to somebody else. After all, who would tell a story from over a hundred years ago with complete dialog and explicit detail?—and in an actual conversation, no less?
Thursday, April 2, 2009
Dracula's Rival - NOT!!
Since I first heard of Stephanie Meyer’s Twilight around last year through murmurs in the dorm, particularly through a dorm-mate who likes reading chick lit. I came under the impression that Twilight is chick lit; chick lit for me is highly unsophisticated and unworthy of my eyes, which I think should be exposed to classical and canonical literature, including those I haven’t finished yet, like Victor Hugo’s Les Misérables and Homer’s epic The Iliad, which, in the words of Lisa Simpson, “practically started the whole Western literary tradition.” (I paused reading the epic at Book 11, just halfway through the entire story.)
I'm not really sure how I came to the subconscious conclusion that Twilight might not be good for me. I'm guessing that because of its being just another vampire novel made me think: “So what’s new?”
Later, I learned that it’s not exactly chick lit; at least not like books like How to Survive a Breakup or Between Dinnertime and the Morning After, which I hear are awful. After all, considering how many people actually love Twilight, I guess it might not be as bad as I think. I don’t believe that many people can be so stupid to fall for something that’s not worth reading, if Twilight is that bad.
So around September or December last year, I thought Twilight could be worth a shot. But in case it was bad, I was unwilling to spend a peso for it. To my delight, my roommate sensed my curiosity and was generous enough to send me the e-books of the entire series.
I’ve read only at least two pages of the first book Twilight and I was unable to continue. The writing was only as good as the average online fan fiction, meaning it’s not even good enough to be published as an expensive book and distributed worldwide.
I think the appeal of the books come from the fact that the characters are attractive and its premise is something that any teenage girl would fall for. But even that is an undignified quality if applied to any proper book. A good book can get anybody’s attention; an excellent book can attract more than its target audience. Harry Potter is not the best novel series ever, but its charm and witty language caught the attention of children and adults alike.
But Twilight—its immature language ruins its chances of being something good to read. Yeah, I would say that the premise is cliched, but there's no telling it would work or not. Obviously, it did, but only to a certain extent. The problem of the book was the writing itself.
After reading excerpts of the first book, I learned that it's not just the beginning of the book that was bad; the rest of it is.
I've read an excerpt of the scene of Bella's first day in school. She describes there how she somehow attracts everyone's attention, how everybody's head turns to her direction. As I remember earlier in the story, Bella does not find herself very attractive with her paleness, so why would anyone else take notice of her? And even if Meyer was using the unreliable narrator tactic when Bella describes her own appearance, it still does not explain why every head would turn to her direction. Even the prettiest girls in existence don't get that kind of attention.
In relation to this, Bella previously resided in Arizona, where she loves the sun. If she loves the sun so much, one would think she would soak herself in its light, giving her a tan. Why and how would she remain so white, then?
Another annoying scene I bumped into is the one where Bella first sees the Cullens. Here, Meyer displays her excessibve dependence on adjectives. She uses "beautiful" and "perfect" more than once. Meyer does not exactly fail to explain why they're beautiful or perfect, but the character's teenage awe gets in the way of making a description that could have been more eloquent than what was printed.
Furthermore, what constitutes beauty or perfection anyway? If Bella describes one of the Cullens to be of an athletic build, what could possibly make that more perfect than Anna Kournikova's body, for instance?
It doesn't mean that she's so vague that I can't see what the scene intends me to. I do, but the language, its limited vocabulary makes it less than it could have been. What makes it worse is that this language makes Bella sound stupid; whether or not she is, the author seems to be making the character's age as an excuse to let the narrative fall apart.
Although I discourage my sisters from reading the book, I am not going to tell people that reading Twilight would show how unintelligent they are. (I've seen online articles that say that.) I won't. But if anybody reads this, let me just say that there are better books to buy. Go get them. If you're into vampire novels in particular, grab Bram Stoker's Dracula. Let's just say that this is where you see what the vampire really is.
I'm not really sure how I came to the subconscious conclusion that Twilight might not be good for me. I'm guessing that because of its being just another vampire novel made me think: “So what’s new?”
Later, I learned that it’s not exactly chick lit; at least not like books like How to Survive a Breakup or Between Dinnertime and the Morning After, which I hear are awful. After all, considering how many people actually love Twilight, I guess it might not be as bad as I think. I don’t believe that many people can be so stupid to fall for something that’s not worth reading, if Twilight is that bad.
So around September or December last year, I thought Twilight could be worth a shot. But in case it was bad, I was unwilling to spend a peso for it. To my delight, my roommate sensed my curiosity and was generous enough to send me the e-books of the entire series.
I’ve read only at least two pages of the first book Twilight and I was unable to continue. The writing was only as good as the average online fan fiction, meaning it’s not even good enough to be published as an expensive book and distributed worldwide.
I think the appeal of the books come from the fact that the characters are attractive and its premise is something that any teenage girl would fall for. But even that is an undignified quality if applied to any proper book. A good book can get anybody’s attention; an excellent book can attract more than its target audience. Harry Potter is not the best novel series ever, but its charm and witty language caught the attention of children and adults alike.
But Twilight—its immature language ruins its chances of being something good to read. Yeah, I would say that the premise is cliched, but there's no telling it would work or not. Obviously, it did, but only to a certain extent. The problem of the book was the writing itself.
After reading excerpts of the first book, I learned that it's not just the beginning of the book that was bad; the rest of it is.
I've read an excerpt of the scene of Bella's first day in school. She describes there how she somehow attracts everyone's attention, how everybody's head turns to her direction. As I remember earlier in the story, Bella does not find herself very attractive with her paleness, so why would anyone else take notice of her? And even if Meyer was using the unreliable narrator tactic when Bella describes her own appearance, it still does not explain why every head would turn to her direction. Even the prettiest girls in existence don't get that kind of attention.
In relation to this, Bella previously resided in Arizona, where she loves the sun. If she loves the sun so much, one would think she would soak herself in its light, giving her a tan. Why and how would she remain so white, then?
Another annoying scene I bumped into is the one where Bella first sees the Cullens. Here, Meyer displays her excessibve dependence on adjectives. She uses "beautiful" and "perfect" more than once. Meyer does not exactly fail to explain why they're beautiful or perfect, but the character's teenage awe gets in the way of making a description that could have been more eloquent than what was printed.
Furthermore, what constitutes beauty or perfection anyway? If Bella describes one of the Cullens to be of an athletic build, what could possibly make that more perfect than Anna Kournikova's body, for instance?
It doesn't mean that she's so vague that I can't see what the scene intends me to. I do, but the language, its limited vocabulary makes it less than it could have been. What makes it worse is that this language makes Bella sound stupid; whether or not she is, the author seems to be making the character's age as an excuse to let the narrative fall apart.
Although I discourage my sisters from reading the book, I am not going to tell people that reading Twilight would show how unintelligent they are. (I've seen online articles that say that.) I won't. But if anybody reads this, let me just say that there are better books to buy. Go get them. If you're into vampire novels in particular, grab Bram Stoker's Dracula. Let's just say that this is where you see what the vampire really is.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

